Author | [HWM Daily] Faction balance: current situation |
Dear Lords,
You can read the article "Faction balance: current situation" here:
http://daily.heroeswm.ru/newscom.php?i=faction-balance-current-situation |
Any analysis data for combat lv15 and above? |
for ElfMoon:
unfortunately, there is no analysis data for combat lv15 and above available now, because the original article includes 9-14 CL only |
Ok. Thank you :) |
Thanks l_e_s_e_n_a. I love the he last sentence in the comments to the statistics of CL 13: "To tell you the truth, it’s hard to believe, but Dwarves lose many battles". |
barbarians suck at higher levels :| |
It is either bad analysis or bad translation of an article (or both?)...A bit of complex statistical analysis is required. |
14CL, last sentence in the comments: "Tribals are balanced." :))
With 63% win percentage, tribals are OP.
Thanks for these stats. |
The most interesting part I think would be to have win ratio of each faction depending of ennemy faction (say elf VS dark demon) but I'm not sure the tool to collect data could handle that.
Btw, if you were to publish similar analysis, it would be easier to read if every graph had the same scale (ej. always go up to 80% even if there is nothing above 70% to quickly compare datas beetween graphics for dfferent CL in a glance) and/or 50% had a specific color (higher are "good" factions; lower, "bad" factions).
Otherwise, it looks like base knight is consistantly weaker, and base necro consistantly stronger except for one level.
Last, there must be a bias in your datas as an average percent of victory different than 50% doesn't look right, though overall it is not very significant.
Wathever, thanks, it was nice to look at and instructive (was it a dwarf player that made the graphs? :p). |
As i mentioned above, other analysis should be performed. (Not knowing the data - if 1v1 or 2v2 or 3v3 were also considered).
Those victories are not independent - since u always play against. So chi-square distribution should be used. Also FL is not considered.
You look for median not mean (since there is a mean square error). Even weighted mean would be better...Also something different than 50% is weird since there is always loser and winner.
Standard is to have 5% alpha deviqtion to be considered as normal...other as bad:-)
Hope balancing on this server is performed on better analysis... |
Those victories are not independent - since u always play against. So chi-square distribution should be used.
I wouldn't use chi test with datas for some factions below 30... FL is a bias, but some players might pick fl potion to bias even more datas.
As for the overall need of a test, I'm not sure how relevant it would be when win ratio ranges from 30% to 70%.
Hope balancing on this server is performed on better analysis...
I believe that while the journal is official, it is fan-made (the journal...). Balance is said to be done on minor tournaments (rather than on CG). |
Thanks for all these posts. In reference to another thread since closed, someone said all the server trusts Arctic.
That poster doesn't speak for all the server. I'm very happy to see another voice with some degree of knowledge posting to us. |
Really nice article! Can we also have an analysis for 15+ please? Also please include 2vs2 and 3vs3 please (weight based or median based). 1vs1 surely isn't a weight to balance things around. eg, i personaly dislike 1vs1 fights and thus not playing them, but love 3vs3 ones(i don't play them either due to money shortage but whatever :P) |
I just translate the articles written by Russian players
some of them (articles) are not perfect, but they are worth reading
In reference to another thread since closed, someone said about my bikini photos
well, guys, if you don't like some articles, you may discuss my bikini photos then
hahaha, it's only a joke ;))) |
I noticed that necromancer is overall the better faction at PvP, atleast according to the statistics. Good to know.
Thanks, i gotta commend you for posting this. |
is this article old or something? because the game has 21 level(and tons of players at 15/15/17/18) |
is this article old or something? because the game has 21 level(and tons of players at 15/15/17/18)
Like l_e_s_e_n_a explained in post 3,there is no data for 15+
I am sure you will get your informatiion soon enough |
Dont shoot the postman! Or the postwoman in that case :P
Get your lazy butts Russian players and start reviewing bigger levels :P
As always nice work |
15/16/17/18 |
I always appreciate any voluntary work for us players. So thanks a lot for all your work and keep coming. |